| | |
| 21 Water American cuisine, casual style dining
21 West Water St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)..............................................................  Tel: 631-725-7500 | |
| American Hotel
Be our guest for Lunch or Dinner and experience why the American Hotel is praised by food and wine critics for its dedication and commitment to excellence.
25 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (P. O. Box 1349)................................................Tel: 631-725-3535 Fax:................................................. 631-725-3573; E-mail:.................. tbc3@theamericanhotel.com Internet:.......................................................................................................... www.theamericanhotel.comYear-round; dinner daily, lunch Sat & Sun only; Map | |
| Aqua East Fine dining, Italian restaurant, price fixe. Catering available. Call for reservations.
17 South Edison St., Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................. Tel: 631-668-4147 E-mail:.......... contact@aquaeastmontauk.com; Internet:................. www.aquaeastmontauk.comDaily 5pm-till last customer, closed Thursdays; Map | |
| B. Smith's
Smith's strikes just the right note, as the owners have thoughtfully allowed the view and the food to take front seat. 1 Bay St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (Long Wharf at Bay St. , P.O. Box 600).................Tel: 631-725-5858 Fax:................................................. 631-725-8943; Internet:..................................... www.bsmith.comLUNCH: Mo-Su 12pm-4pm, DINNER: Su-Th 6pm-10pm, Fr-Sa 6pm-11pm; Map | |
| Bay Street Cafe
5 Bay St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)................................................................................ Tel: 631-725-9613 | |
| Beacon A light and breezy menu has been created to match the casual bistro setting.
8 West Water St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn).................................................................Tel: 631-725-7088 | |
| Bird on the Roof Cute, friendly and relaxed. The most interesting breakfast in Montauk.
47 South Elmwood Ave., Montauk (EHmptn) (At Main St.).................................... Tel: 631-668-5833 | |
| Breakwater Cafe
Contemporary American cuisine with international influences set inside a romantic, ornately designed Tudor-esque manor; pricey gourmet foods. 236 Edgemere Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................... Tel: 631-668-3949 Serving dinner; year-round; daily in summer; closed Mon & Tue rest of year; Map | |
| Caffe Monte Serving authentic Italian cuisine.
Freshly baked breads, pies & cakes all made on premises. 290 Old Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn) (at Gurney's Inn)................................Tel: 631-668-2345 Internet:........................................................................ www.gurneys-inn.com/Dining/Caffe-Monte.htm | |
| Cantina Bar & Grill
Montauk (EHmptn) (5 S Emerson Ave)........................................................................Tel: 631-267-2200
| |
| Caswell's
Edison Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................................Tel: 631-668-0303
| |
| Chinda's Noyac Thai House Authentic Thai cuisine.
3284 Noyac Rd., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)....................................................................Tel: 631-725-1374 | |
| Circle Restaurant
Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................................... Tel: 631-668-9705 | |
| Corner, The
1 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn).............................................................................. Tel: 631-725-9760 Internet:..................................................................................................... www.cornerbarsagharbor.com | |
| Dave's Grill Known for its incredibly fresh seafood, steak, pasta and pasta selections.
468 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-9190 E-mail:................................. eat@davesgrill.com; Internet:................................ www.davesgrill.comDinner; May-Oct; daily June - Sept except Weds; May, June & Oct open; Map | |
| Dock House
Long Wharf, Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (Long Wharf)....................................................Tel: 631-725-7555
| |
| Dock, The
Saloon with good food, on the harbor, next to the commercial fishing fleet. Serving lunch, dinner and late night. Montauk (EHmptn) (Town Dock)..................................................................................Tel: 631-668-9778 Internet:............................................................................................................ www.thedockmontauk.com | |
| Dockside Bar & Grill Restaurant
26 Bay St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)..............................................................................Tel: 631-725-7100 | |
| Duryea's Lobster Deck
Pick up some whole lobsters to take home, or sit on the outside deck and get your lobster roll, lobster dinner, or fish burger to eat on paper plates with plastic utensils . There are no pretensions here. 65 Tuthill Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)..............................................................................Tel: 631-668-2410 E-mail:............................. pbd3@worldnet.att.net; Internet:......................... www.peconic.net/duryeaOpen daily year-round except Sun, 7-4; deck open May-Oct daily noon-7; Map | |
| East by Northeast
Favorites from the far east to the northeast; Asian and American cuisine includes seafood, steaks, salads, specialty drinks, and more. 51 Edgemere Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)......................................................................Tel: 631-668-2872 E-mail:................. msalahie@harvest2000.com; Internet:................... www.harvest2000.com/eneFeb-Dec; in summer dinner daily; fewer days rest of year; brunch Sun; Map | |
| Estia's Little Kitchen All American, straightforward honest food.
1615 Sag Harbor Tpk., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)........................................................Tel: 631-725-1045 Open daily except for Tuesdays for breakfast, lunch and dinner; Map | |
| Gianni's Bar & Grill Excellent creative New American style seafood.
Superb service and a spacious attractive dining room. 17 South Edison St., Montauk (EHmptn) ((S. Etna Ave.))....................................... Tel: 631-668-0303 | |
| Giannis Pizza
Montauk (EHmptn) (54 South Erie Ave).......................................................................Tel: 631-668-8888
| |
| Gig Shack, 668 The
Cafe style food to go, bar, dancing, and live music; opens Memorial Day weekend. 782 Main St., Montauk (EHmptn)...............................................................................Tel: 631-668-2727 E-mail:........................... lewgrossdds@aol.com; Internet:..................... www.668thegigshack.com | |
| Giordano's Ristorante Italiano
Italian specialties and pizza in cozy restaurant located near historic Village of Sag Harbor Long Island NY 3360 Noyac Rd., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)....................................................................Tel: 631-725-4444 | |
| Golden Pear Cafe
111 Main Street, Sag Harbor (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-725-2270 Fax:.......................................................................................................................................... 631-725-7398 Su-Th 7-17:30, FrSa 7-22:30; Map | |
| Gosman's Dock Restaurant
Gosman's is the ultimate fish house-casual and noted for its good fresh fish. There's a view from the dining room of the fishing fleet entering the harbor. Enjoy seafood served in the Gosman's Restaurant, Gosman's Clam Bar or the Inlet Cafe. 500 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-2549 Tel: ................................................. 631-668-5330; Internet:................................ www.gosmans.comMid Apr - mid Oct; Mem. Day - Labor Day lunch and dinner daily; fewer days rest of season; Map | |
| Harvest on Fort Pond
Popular, family-style seafood restaurant on the waterfront; lobster cakes, steamed mussels, bruschetta, salads, calamari, pizzas, pasta, salmon, and much more. 11 South Emery St., Montauk (EHmptn)..................................................................Tel: 631-668-5574 E-mail:............... JGonzalez@harvest2000.com; Internet:........................... www.harvest2000.comDinner mid-Mar-Dec; daily in summer fewer days rest of season; Map | |
| Havana Beach Club Restaurant
Authentic Cuban cuisine served indoors, for take-out, or on the beach; flavored mojitos, sandwiches, espresso, cappuccino, bistro, and other favorites. 448 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-6677 Tel: ................................................. 866-377-8132; Fax:.................................................. 631-668-6676 E-mail:.............. info@havanabeachclubny.com; Internet:.............. www.havanabeachclubny.com | |
| Hideaway, The
Nestled in the Diamond Cove Marina, come enjoy Mexican barbecue and seafood after your day of boating. 364 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-6592 | |
| Il Capuccino Ristorante Il Capuccino is the traditional Italian restaurant.
The chef's philosophy is to keep the food old-world style and keep prices modest. 30 Madison St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (P.O. Box 1438)..........................................Tel: 631-725-2747 Fax:................................................. 631-725-5783; Internet:............................. www.ilcapuccino.comDinner year-round; daily; except major holidays; Map | |
| Il Farole
Edgemere, Montauk (EHmptn) (at the Montauk Manor)........................................... Tel: 631-668-0816 | |
| Jeff & Eddy's Seafood
Moderately priced New England-style, casual seafood joint and an auxiliary seafood market. Come early for that fresh-from-the-boat fin food. 62 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)............................................................................Tel: 631-725-0055 E-mail:................................... jeff@jeffeddys.com; Internet:.................................. www.jeffeddys.comLunch & dinner year-round; daily; Map | |
| JLX Bistro
Trendy and fun place for lunch, brunch or dinner on the East End serving bistro menu 16 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) ((between Nassau & Water Sts.)).....................Tel: 631-725-9100 | |
| John Papas Cafe
126 South Emerson Ave., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................Tel: 631-668-1511 | |
| John's Drive In Restaurant
Affordable American favorites from this landmark diner; burgers, shakes, fries, chicken, homemade ice cream, and more. 695 Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................... Tel: 631-668-5515 | |
| John's Pancake House
Over 16 varieties of pancakes--waffles, crepes, burgers, soups & chowders. 721 Main St., Montauk (EHmptn)...............................................................................Tel: 631-668-2383 | |
| La Super Rica
1 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn).............................................................................. Tel: 631-725-3388 | |
| Lakeside
Affordable seafood in laid-back, outdoor dining by day and a lounge-club scene at night; lobster, calamari, fish tacos, quesadillas, burgers, and clams on the half shell. 183 Edgemere St., Montauk (EHmptn).................................................................... Tel: 631-668-3455 | |
| Luigi's Restaurant Montauk's "Little Italy". Fine Italian dining.
Delicious food cooked to perfection & served in a comfortable atmosphere. 41 South Euclid Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)..................................................................Tel: 631-668-3212 | |
| Magnolia Restaurant
29 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (at Bay St.).........................................................Tel: 631-725-0101 | |
| Mannuci's at the Manor Menu features seafood, veal and a variety of pastas
236 Edgemere, Montauk (EHmptn) ((between Elwell St. & Fenwick Pl.))...............Tel: 631-668-4400 | |
| Manucci's
Italian and seafood cuisine; bottled wine, clams, salads, eggplant, mussels, calamari, pasta dinners, chicken breast, shrimp, filet mignon, and much more. 440 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-4455 Fax:................................................. 631-668-1300; E-mail:................................. info@manuccis.com Internet:........................................................................................................................ www.manuccis.com | |
| Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina Breeze's Cafe.
Enjoy your favorite cocktail in an outdoor waterfront setting. Music, daily drink specials. 32 Star Island Road, Montauk (EHmptn) (off West Lake Dr.).................................Tel: 631-668-3100 Toll-Free:.................................................631--888; Fax:.................................................. 631-668-6181 E-mail:................. info@montaukyachtclub.com; Internet:................. www.montaukyachtclub.com | |
| Mumbo Gumbo Crab House Seafood, Martini bar and lounge
62 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)............................................................................Tel: 631-725-7427 | |
| Naturally Good Food & Cafe
Healthy food alternatives from natural, organic products sold at market and served in cafe; breakfast tortillas, oatmeal, pancakes, fresh fruit, smoothies, chai, tea, coffee, soups, salads, vegetables, vitamins, and much more. 38 South Etna Ave., Montauk (EHmptn) (38 S Etna Ave)........................................ Tel: 631-668-9030 | |
| Navy Road Restaurant ...an enjoyable find for great eclectic dishes...
- Zagats 2002 Long Island Restaurants Montauk (EHmptn) (16 Navy Rd.)................................................................................ Tel: 631-668-1064 | |
| New Paradise Cafe Serious food at this terrific restaurant.
Black and white tile floors, wainscoted walls, and reed chairs give it a French cafe atmosphere, and there's a little deck in back for outside dining. 126 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)..........................................................................Tel: 631-725-6080 Fax:.......................................................................................................................................... 631-725-2578 Breakfast, brunch, lunch, dinner; year-round, daily; Map | |
| O'Murphy's Pub
Moderately priced Irish pub with extensive drink selection and fine food; burgers, sandwiches, wraps, shepherd's pie, chicken, children's menu, and more. 99 Edgemere St., Montauk (EHmptn) (On the Green, Opposite The Tower)......... Tel: 631-668-5005 | |
| Oasis Waterfront Restaurant & Bar
Modern American cuisine with an emphasis on seafood. The chef loves to work with seasonal local ingredients. 3253 Noyac Rd., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (at Mill Creek Marina)...............................Tel: 631-725-7110 Fax:................................................. 631-725-7221; E-mail:...................... info@oasishamptons.com Internet:............................................................................................................. www.oasishamptons.comServing dinner Thursday through Sunday from 5:30; Map | |
| Oyster Pond Restaurant & Bar
New American cuisinie served on and off season; spicy tuna rolls, crab cakes with salsa, tempura shrimp, caesar salad, seafood chowder, individual pizzas, lobster, grilled pork chops, and more. 4 South Elmwood Ave., Montauk (EHmptn) (P.O. Box 1900).................................Tel: 631-668-4200 Dinner Feb- Dec; in summer daily, off-season open fewer days; Map | |
| Plaza Restaurant Diner type restaurant serving traditional American cuisine
Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................................... Tel: 631-668-9500 | |
| Point Bar & Grill, The Bar and grill serving sushi.
Dinner starting at 4pm with late night menu. 697 Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................... Tel: 631-668-1500 | |
| Primavera Pizza
Montauk Long Island Pizzeria homemade focaccia sandwiches, catering available 54 South Erie Ave., Montauk (EHmptn)....................................................................Tel: 631-668-1601 | |
| Provisions Natural food market that features creative vegetarian fare for breafast & lunch.
Main, Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (Corner of Bay & Division Sts.).....................................Tel: 631-725-3636 Mcc | |
| Quinn's Tavern Burgers, seafood, cold beer in lively simple setting
432 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn) (at Tipperary Inn)......................................Tel: 631-668-6818 | |
| Restaurante Marimig
Menu composed primarily of Dominican with Latino staples - Zagats 2003 Long Island Restaurants 166 Nesconset Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn) ((Murder St.))........................................Tel: 631-476-5760 Internet:........................................................................................................................... www.marimig.com | |
| | |
| Ruschmeyer's Restaurant & Inn
Family favorite, affordable fish, meats, chicken, pastas, and daily specials; option for lake front, outdoor dining, on the patio, overlooking Fort Pond. 161 Second House Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................... Tel: 631-668-2877 E-mail:.......................... info@ruschmeyers.com; Internet:.......................... www.ruschmeyers.com | |
| Sag Harbor Grill Grilled meat and seafood dishes, casual dining place
16 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)............................................................................Tel: 631-725-6060 | |
| Sail Inn Fresh seafood, steaks, chops, daily specials.
548 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-2800 | |
| Salivar's Restaurant
Fresh fish and seafood, try clam chowder specialty; waterview patio, open 24 hours for breakfast, lunch & dinner. 470 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-2555 | |
| Sausages - Pizza & Pastabilities
East Hampton Long Island Italian eatery; pizza, sandwiches, pasta dishes, and all the usual famous Italian dishes. 780 Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................... Tel: 631-668-1144 Mo-Fr 11-22, Su, Sa 11-24, Mon-Fr 11am-10pm, Sa-Su 11am-12am; Map | |
| Sea Grill ...
The new chef gets the food right, replacing what was a pedestrian New American seafood menu with a Nouvelle Italian roster... - Zagats 2002 Long Island Restaurants 290 Old Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn) (Gurney's Inn, between Fir Ln. & Maple St.).............. Map Tel: .......................................................................................................................................... 631-668-2345 Internet:............................................................................ www.gurneys-inn.com/Dining/Sea-Grille.htm | |
| Sen Japanese Restaurant
Folks come for the super-fresh sushi and other gourmet Japanense delights. 23 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)............................................................................Tel: 631-725-1774 Internet:................................................................................................................ www.senrestaurant.comYear-round; dinner daily, lunch Fri & Sat; closed Tues. off-season; Map | |
| Shagwong Restaurant
Reasonably priced, affordable seafood, meat, chops, steaks, soups, and appetizers; brunch, lunch, early bird, dinner, and late night supper. 774 Main St., Montauk (EHmptn)...............................................................................Tel: 631-668-3050 E-mail:............................... info@shagwong.com; Internet:............................... www.shagwong.com | |
| Shebeen
 Edgemere Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................................... Tel: 631-668-9880 Edgemere Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................................... Tel: 631-668-9880 | |
| Sing City
Long Island Ave., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)..................................................................Tel: 631-725-9888
| |
| Sole Backyard Restaurant
Backyard at Sole; full restaurant dining, bar, catering for guests, and special events including DJs, beach chill outs, and more. 90 Second House Rd., Montauk (EHmptn) (P.O. Box 639).................................... Tel: 631-668-9739 | |
| Spinnaker's
American and international menu, casual attire, dark wood and brass accents decoration 63 Main St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn)............................................................................Tel: 631-725-9353 Su-Th 11:30-22, FrSa 11:30-23; Map | |
| Star Deck Grill Enjoy cocktails while overlooking Montauk Harbor.
Serving breakfast, lunch & dinner. Fresh local seafood, salads, 1/2 lb. burgers, daily specials. Montauk (EHmptn) (P.O. Box 2130)............................................................................ Tel: 631-668-5052 Internet:................................................................................................ www.starislandyc.com/restaurant | |
| Surfside Inn Overlooking the ocean with fireside bar serving breakfast, lunch & dinner.
680 Old Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn) (Surfside Inn at Overlook Park)........Tel: 631-668-5958 | |
| The Munch Box Great place for casual lunch
The Plaza, Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................................... Tel: 631-668-5009 | |
| Trail's End Restaurant Fine American cuisine. Warmth & charm of yesteryear.
Old-fashioned turkey, LI duckling, prime ribs, steak, lobster, seafood, pastas. Edgemere Rd., Montauk (EHmptn)........................................................................... Tel: 631-668-2133 Internet:........................................................................................... www.montauk-online.com/trailsend/ | |
| Tutto Il Giorno
A gourmet Italian kitchen in the heart of Sag Harbor! Classic Tuscan fare. Dinners, parties, special events & cooking classes & take-out. 6 Bay St., Sag Harbor (EHmptn) (Located at the Base of the Bridge).......................Tel: 631-725-7009 | |
| Vastios Pizza Village Montauk Long Island pizzeria voted the best pizza in Montauk
700 Montauk Hwy., Montauk (EHmptn)................................................................... Tel: 631-668-2232 | |
| West Cove Seafood Restaurant
448 West Lake Dr., Montauk (EHmptn)...................................................................Tel: 631-668-2785 | |
| Wok And Roll
Gourmet Chinese cuisine, specializing in seafood, including cooking your own freshly caught fish; also pork, chicken, beef, vegetarian, and all other Chinese favorites. 716 Main St., Montauk (EHmptn)...............................................................................Tel: 631-668-6688 | |
