Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Seafood Restaurants in Hamptons Long Island, NY

Updated Oct 05 2014 06:29 PM EST with 29 listings
Long Island is a great place to get seafood. There is much fresh fish and shell fish caught right off of our shores. Head in any direction on Long Island east, west, north or south and you are bound to find a highly rated seafood restaurant.
Seafood Restaurants in Hamptons Long Island, NY

Bostwick's Seafood Grill & Oyster Bar

The restaurant offers glorious views of the harbor and sunsets. Gentle prices and casual dress code make this an exceptionally popular spot.
423 Three Mile Harbor Rd., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-1111


You can get prepared sandwiches, salads, and entrees, and this popular caterer can often be found at the Hamptons' snazziest fun-raisers.
235 -A North Sea Rd., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-6437
Tel: 631-283-6669

Coast Grill

This wonderful restaurant has been serving up fresh fish, prepared in a simple, straightforward manner. The menu isn't confined to seafood.
1109 Noyac Rd., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-2277

Cyril's Fish House

Great, fresh seafood, cold drinks and fun atmosphere
2167 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-7993

Dockers Waterside Restaurant

Fresh seafood, steaks, lobsters, live entertainment, indoor and outdoor dining and more.
94 Dune Road, East Quogue NY 11942 Tel 631-653-0653
Fax: 631-653-6949; E-mail: dockers@lrjm.com
Website: dockerswaterside.com


The cusine features local produce and seafood. An outdoor patio with a fountain and extensive landscaping is planned.
8 Fresno Pl., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-8700
Fax: 631-324-1019; Website: fresnorestaurant.com

Indian Cove Restaurant & Marina

American-French/ fresh local seafood and waterfront dining on the Shinnecock Canal.
258 East Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 On the Shinnecock Canal, Tel 631-728-5366

Jeff & Eddy's Seafood

Moderately priced New England-style, casual seafood joint and an auxiliary seafood market. Come early for that fresh-from-the-boat fin food.
62 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-0055
E-mail: jeff@jeffeddys.com; Website: jeffeddys.com

Lobster Inn

Fresh local seafood in a casual setting overlooking Cold Spring Pond
162 Inlet Rd., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-1525
Fax: 631-283-8159

Lobster Roll South Side

Moderatley priced, seafood lunch; lobster bisque, putter fish, crab cakes, the famous lobster roll, kids menu, wine, beer, and much more.
1980 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett NY 11930 at Napeague, Tel 631-267-3740


Fabulous waterside and sunset views; live entertainment some nights; once you are seated, lobsters-both steamed and stuffed-are the way to go.
365 Dune Road, Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-6900
E-mail: info@oaklandsrestaurant.com; Website: oaklandsrestaurant.com

Ocean Grill

Mediterranean seafood slanted menu of chef Frank Caniglia
2495 Montauk Hwy., Bridgehampton NY 11932 at Ocean Rd., Tel 631-537-5665


The right pseudo-French-bistro setting. Light seasonal french with an emphansis on seafood.
2468 Main St., Bridgehampton NY 11932 Tel 631-537-5110
Fax: 631-537-9534; E-mail: info@pierresbridgehampton.com
Website: pierresbridgehampton.com

Plaza Cafe

Specializing in seafood, this critically acclaimed restaurant receives high praise for it's innovative dishes, professional service and welcoming atmosphere.
61 Hill St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-9323
E-mail: info@plazacafe.us; Website: plazawinedinners.com

Riccardo's Seafood

The menu is a reflection of the chef's Latin heritage. There's live Latin music at brunch on Sunday.
313 Three Mile Harbor Rd., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-0000

Scales & Tales

North Phillips Ave., Speonk NY 11972 Tel 631-325-1554

Tide Runners Restaurant

The menu is mostly composed of seafood. You can get lobster, salmon, tuna, crab cakes, and mussels or you could come for the view and the scene.
7 North Rd., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-7373
E-mail: Tiderunners7@aol.com; Website: tiderunners.com

Seafood Restaurants (12 listings total)

Amagansett Fish Co

Seafood cuisine, cozy environment, dine in or take out; reservations recommended
501 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-6697

B. Smith's

Smith's strikes just the right note, as the owners have thoughtfully allowed the view and the food to take front seat.
1 Bay St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-5858
Fax: 631-725-8943; Website: bsmith.com


American seafood cuisine
36 Main St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-6206

Before the Bridge

Seafood American-Eclectic restaurant; different specials every night.
78 Foster Ave., Hampton Bays NY 11968 Tel 631-728-9111
Fax: 631-728-4442

Clam Bar at Napeague

Perfect after beach stop; outdoor, casual, serving lobster rolls and cold beer
13595 Montauk Hwy., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-6348

Dock House

Long Wharf, Sag Harbor NY 11963 Long Wharf, Tel 631-725-7555

Margarita Island

Traditional American seafood restaurant
43 Canoe Place Rd., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-0599
Fax: 631-728-4408

Mattituck Shellfish

Come and enjoy our delicious seafood dishes.
468 Montauk Hwy., East Quogue NY 11942 Tel 631-653-5040

Multi Aqua Culture Systems

Restaurant with stunning view of Gardiners Bay serving fresh seafood, including lemony lobster roll and more
429 Cranberry Hole Rd., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-3341

Mumbo Gumbo Crab House

Seafood, Martini bar and lounge
62 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-7427

Sunwater's Grill

Casual affordable, waterfront restaurant, serving tasty twin lobster and prime ribs.
369 Dune Road, Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-1722

Three Aces Clam Bar & Restaurant

Seafood specialties in casual atmosphere
181 West Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-2260