Look through our alphabetical list of categories

Italian Restaurants in East End Long Island, NY

Updated Oct 05 2014 05:19 PM EST with 71 listings
Italian restaurants are famous for their wide variety of pasta dishes and pizzas. They also offer creamy tiramisus and canoli desserts.
Italian Restaurants in East End Long Island, NY

Italian Restaurants (70 listings total)

A Touch of Venice

Italian specialities and fresh seafood. Local wines by the bottle and the glass. Has seasonal hours: summer 7 days a week 12 to 9 or later. As winter progresses, closed more days. Call ahead.
2255 Wickman Avenue, Mattituck NY 11952 Tel 631-298-5851
Website: touchofvenice.com

Acqua Terre

Italian fare from eight regions of Northern Italy.
17 South Edison St., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-6828

aMano Osteria & Wine bar

Fine Italian cuisine, expanded wine list includes a large selection of Long Island's favorites.
13560 Main Rd., Mattituck NY 11952 Tel 631-298-4800
Website: amanorestaurant.com

Annona - Closed

112 Riverhead Rd., Westhampton Beach NY 11978

Aqua East

Fine dining, Italian restaurant, price fixe. Catering available. Call for reservations.
17 South Edison St., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-4147
E-mail: contact@aquaeastmontauk.com; Website: aquaeastmontauk.com

Armand's

Italian pizza and seafood
1271 Noyac Rd., Southampton NY Tel 631-283-9742

Basilico

The restaurant has that fresh, airy feeling of Sante Fe, but the food is strictly northern Italian.
10 Windmill Lane, Southampton NY 11978 Tel 631-283-7987

Bella Gusto Ristorante

Great Italian food and pizza in a beautiful setting
6278 Route 25a., Wading River NY 11792 Tel 631-929-3939

Bertucci's Brick Oven Pizzeria

Like the original pizzerias and trattorias of Italy, Bertucci's started as a place for friends, family and neighbors to gather. Carryout and sit down dining
Website: bertuccis.com

Boccacini

Pizzeria and pastaria offering many traditional family recipes, wood-fired pizzas, creative salads and unforgettable pasta dishes
42 East Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 King Kullen Shop. Cntr., Tel 631-728-2400
Website: boccacini.com

Caffe Monte

Serving authentic Italian cuisine. Freshly baked breads, pies & cakes all made on premises.
290 Old Montauk Hwy., Montauk NY 11954 at Gurney's Inn, Tel 631-668-2345
Website: gurneys-inn.com

Casa Basso

Serving the finest Italian cuisine since 1932.
59 Montauk Hwy., Westhampton NY 11977 Tel 631-288-1841

Chez & Chez

Serving Italian cuisine in a friendly atmosphere.
290 Montauk Hwy., East Hampton NY Tel 631-329-1133

Christopher's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Blue Point Long Island NY specialized pizzeria and Italian restaurant, extensive pizza, lunch, dinner and catering menus
33 Montauk Highway, Blue Point NY 11715 Tel 631-363-8300
E-mail: Mark@Christphers-pizzeria.com; Website: christophers-pizzeria.com

Cinelli's Pizzeria

Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant, leading independent delivery system providing quality, service, & innovation
E-mail: info@cinellis.com; Website: cinellis-ny.com

Cittanuova

Presenting affordable Italian fare.
29 Newtown Lane, East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-6300
Website: cittanuova.com

Conca D' Oro Pizza Restaurant

Sag Harbor Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant
103 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-3167

Dee Angelos Supper Club

Classic Italian cuisine served in an atmosphere reminiscent of New York's "Little Italy."
141 Montauk Hwy., Westhampton NY 11977 Tel 631-288-0808

Edgewater Restaurant

Italian/Mediterranean cuisine; outdoor dining available overlooking the Shinnecock Bay.
295 East Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-723-2323
Fax: 631-723-1901; Website: edgewaterrestaurant.com

Felice's Italian Restaurant

Italian restaurant located in beautiful South shore area
37 Main St., Amagansett NY 11930 Tel 631-267-3339

Fierro's Restaurant & Pizzeria

East Hampton Long Island NY sit down dining or carry out pizza
104 Park Pl., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-5751

Giordano's Ristorante Italiano

Italian specialties and pizza in cozy restaurant located near historic Village of Sag Harbor Long Island NY
3360 Noyac Rd., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-4444

Gurney's Inn

Italian and international menu. Sunset ocean front seating is available and so is live music.
290 Old Montauk Hwy., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-2345
Tel: 631-668-2660; Tel: 800-848-7639
Fax: 631-668-3576; Website: gurneys-inn.com

Harvest on Fort Pond

Popular, family-style seafood restaurant on the waterfront; lobster cakes, steamed mussels, bruschetta, salads, calamari, pizzas, pasta, salmon, and much more.
11 South Emery St., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-5574
E-mail: JGonzalez@harvest2000.com; Website: harvest2000.com

Il Capuccino Ristorante

Il Capuccino is the traditional Italian restaurant. The chef's philosophy is to keep the food old-world style and keep prices modest.
30 Madison St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 P.O. Box 1438, Tel 631-725-2747
Fax: 631-725-5783; Website: ilcapuccino.com

Il Farole

Edgemere, Montauk NY at the Montauk Manor, Tel 631-668-0816

Jeneen's

Restaurant and bar serving Italian and American cuisine
367 Three Mile Harbor Rd., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-9024

JLX Bistro

Trendy and fun place for lunch, brunch or dinner on the East End serving bistro menu
16 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-9100

Julia's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Riverhead Long Island NY Pizzeria and Italian Restaurant specialties and pizza, located near Peconic River
29 East Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-369-8332

Junior's Pizza

Pizza and Italian specialties; salads, entrees, pastas, order by phone or online.
Website: juniorsli.com

La Capannina

Lindenhurst Long Island NY gourmet pizza, pasta dinners & catering for all occasions
364 Montauk Hwy., Wainscott NY 11975 Tel 631-537-2626
Website: capanninarestaurant.com

La Parmigiana Restaurant & Deli

La Parmigiana Restaurant in Southampton NY 11968 is a great place for Good Southern Italian food and deserts. Stop in for some Tiramisu and espresso.
44 Hampton Rd., Southampton NY 11968 betw Main & Pine St, Tel 631-283-8030
Website: laparmigianarestaurant.com

La Volpe Ristorante

Center Moriches Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant special wine dinners, which consist of a five-course meal - with a different wine paired with each course
611 Montauk Highway, Center Moriches NY 11934 Tel 631-874-3819
Fax: 631-874-2197; E-mail: info@LaVolpeRestaurant.net
Website: lavolperestaurant.net

Lapizzaiola Restaurant & Pizzeria

Southhampton Long Island NY Italian restaurant and pizzeria
801 Country Rd. 39, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-6770

Lenny's Pizza & Restaurant

Mattituck Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant complete dinner specials
11947 Main Rd., Mattituck NY 11947 Tel 631-722-8589
Tel: 631-722-8591

Luigi's Italian Specialities

199 Pantigo Rd., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-329-0558

Luigi's Restaurant

Montauk's "Little Italy". Fine Italian dining. Delicious food cooked to perfection & served in a comfortable atmosphere.
41 South Euclid Rd., Montauk NY 11954 Tel 631-668-3212

Manucci's

Italian and seafood cuisine; bottled wine, clams, salads, eggplant, mussels, calamari, pasta dinners, chicken breast, shrimp, filet mignon, and much more.
440 West Lake Dr., Montauk NY 11954 Fax 631-668-1300
Tel: 631-668-4455; E-mail: info@manuccis.com
Website: manuccis.com

Mario's Pizza

High quality food made with the finest ingredients, personalized service, unsurpassed value and the traditions of long ago
Website: mariospizzaonline.com

Mario's Pizzeria and Restaurant

Restaurant combines old-world charm with modern-day culinary masterpieces for a unique experience. Or indulge in steaming hot pizza at home, convenient takeout and delivery services
Website: mariospizzeria.com

Mary Jane's Restaurant

Extraordinarily good Italian food, served and priced individually or family-style.
126 North Main St., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-8008
E-mail: maryjane@hamptons.com; Website: maryjanesrestaurant.com

Matto

Elegant restaurant with bar serving eclectic Italian menu and thin crusted pizzas; indoor seating and outdoor patio available
104 North Main St., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-329-0200
Fax: 631-329-0224; Take-Out: 631-329-0255
Website: mattorestaurant.com

Micheal Angelo Pizzeria

Mattituck Long Island NY pizzeria & Italian food in a quiet and lovely environment
10095 Main Rd., Mattituck NY 11952 Mattituck Plaza, Tel 631-298-4100

Michelangelo Pizzeria and Restaurant

Cutchogue Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant
31455 Main Rd., Cutchogue NY Tel 631-298-0230

Nick & Toni's

Sensational food. A 620-degree wood-burning oven prepares meat with crackly crisp skin and tender, juicy meat.
136 North Main St., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-3550
Website: nickandtonis.com

Pagano's

Pagano's Restaurant located on Main Road, Southold Long Island contains a cozy style ambiance with a touch of Italy
53345 Main Rd., Southold NY 11971 Feather Hill Shop. Cntr., Tel 631-765-6109
Website: paganos.com

Parto's Restaurant

Italian restaurant, pizzeria & cafe.
12 West Main St., Riverhead NY 11901 Tel 631-727-4828
Tel: 631-727-4849; Fax: 631-727-4851
Website: partosrestaurant.com

Paul's Italian Restaurant

Serving pizza, burgers, steak, fresh local seafood, homemade soups and much more for eat-in or take-out; offers catering, delivery, and a full bar.
21 Hill, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-1861
E-mail: info@paulsitalianrestaurant.com; Website: paulsitalianrestaurant.com

Pomodorino

Excellent Italian food famous for its tomatoes and sauce; catering, parties, and special events welcome.
All Long Island NY
Website: pomodorino.com

Pomodoro Dolce Restaurant & Bar (Sweet Tomato's) - Shelter Island Heights

Charming restored storefront, Italian continental cuisine, indoor & outdoor dining.
15 Grand Ave., Shelter Island Heights NY 11965 Tel 631-749-4114
Fax: 631-749-4124

Pomodoro Dolce Restaurant & Bar (Sweet Tomato's) - Shelter Island Heights

Charming restored storefront, Italian continental cuisine, indoor & outdoor dining.
15 Grand Ave., Shelter Island Heights NY 11965 Tel 631-749-4114
Fax: 631-749-4124

Porto Bello

...a wonderful meal from start to finish... - Zagats 2002 Long Island New York
74825 Main Rd., Greenport NY 11944 Tel 631-477-1717

Porto Bello Ristorante

An upscale, Northern Italian restaurant set just outside the town of Greenport, serving lunch and dinner seven days a week, reservations recommended, accepting Visa, Mastercard and Discover
1410 Manhasset Avenue, Greenport NY Tel 631-477-1515
Website: portobellonorthfork.com

Robert's

An intimate an utterly romantic restaurant. There's a preponderance of seafood on the menu.
755 Montauk Hwy., Water Mill NY 11976 Tel 631-726-7171

Rosemary's Restaurant

Rosemary's menu features a wide array of creative Italian dishes located in one of the area's most pleasant settings
5 West Main St., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-723-3412
Fax: 631-723-3497

Ruby Red Inc

Serving the cuisine of Naples, Italy; lounge and wine bar with tapas menu.
290 Montauk Hwy., East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-907-8030

Sam's Restaurant

East Hampton Long Island NY classic spot, great food, great prices, great location
36 Newtown Lane, East Hampton NY 11937 Tel 631-324-5900
Website: samsrestaurant.org

Sant Ambroeus

Watermelon-colored Ultra-suede banquettes and bentwood chairs offer sophisticated backdrops for the wonderful meat dishes, risottos, pastas ,and salads.
30 Main St., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-283-1233

Saracen

Southern Mediterrean fare, glass-enclosed porch overlooking Georgica Pond; champagne brunch on Sunday.
108 Wainscott Stone, Wainscott NY 11975 Tel 631-537-6255

Sbarro

Fresh, traditional Italian cuisine serving famous pizza, delicious seafood, vegetable pastas, salads, sandwiches, and homemade desserts in a casual atmosphere
Tel 800-456-4837
Website: www.sbarro.com

Sergio's

Riverhead Long Island NY pizzeria and Italian restaurant, fresh homemade cannolis
739 Old Country Rd., Riverhead NY 11901 Walmart Shopping Center, Tel 631-369-1057

Tuscan House - Riverhead

Paninik Italian sandwiches, pizzette, brick oven pizza, soup and salad combos, more.
673 Osborn Ave., Riverhead NY Tel 631-727-2330

Tuscan House - Southampton

Regional Italian cuisine; open year round, call for reservations.
10 Windmill Lane, Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-287-8703

Tutto Il Giorno

A gourmet Italian kitchen in the heart of Sag Harbor! Classic Tuscan fare. Dinners, parties, special events & cooking classes & take-out.
6 Bay St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-7009

Uncle Joe's Italian Restaurant

Hampton Bays NY Freshly prepared Italian food and crispy crust pizza.
258 West Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-1234
Fax: 631-728-4909

Villa Paul

Upscale traditional Italian cuisine.
162 West Montauk Hwy., Hampton Bays NY 11946 Tel 631-728-3261

Villa Tuscono

Gourmet Italian food in beautiful Hamptons location
336 Montauk Hwy., Southampton NY 11968 Tel 631-728-7262

Vincenzo's Pizza

Sag Harbor Long Island NY pizzeria, call ahead for take-out
2 Main St., Sag Harbor NY 11963 Tel 631-725-7760

World Pie

Bridgehampton Long Island NY pizzeria. Global Italian menu is unique and ambitious. Fun spot always crowded with a nice mix.
2402 Montauk Hwy., Bridgehampton NY 11932

Sicilian Restaurants (1 listings total)

Ciao Baby

Long Island New York Italian restaurants very well reviewed catering homemade fresh mozerella eggplant rollatini calamari baked clams Sicilian rice balls shrimp scampi tuna italian spring rolls and much more
Website: caiobabyrestaurant.com